In his inaugural season as Alabama’s head coach, Kalen DeBoer faced significant challenges, culminating in a 19-13 loss to Michigan in the ReliaQuest Bowl on January 1, 2025. A focal point of criticism has been DeBoer’s unwavering commitment to quarterback Jalen Milroe, despite inconsistent performances throughout the 2024 season.
Milroe’s struggles were evident in the ReliaQuest Bowl, where he completed 16 of 32 passes for 192 yards, throwing one touchdown and one interception. His mobility, typically a strength, was neutralized by Michigan’s defense, limiting him to just 7 rushing yards on 16 attempts. Despite these difficulties, DeBoer did not consider a quarterback change during the game, expressing faith in Milroe’s competitive spirit.
This loyalty has drawn scrutiny, especially after Alabama’s unexpected 40-35 loss to Vanderbilt earlier in the season, a game in which Milroe’s performance was subpar. Critics argue that DeBoer’s reluctance to bench Milroe, even when faced with repeated turnovers and offensive stagnation, contributed to the Crimson Tide’s underwhelming 9-4 record—their first season without at least 10 wins since 2007.
Former Alabama linebacker Joshua McMillon publicly criticized the coaching staff, suggesting that the offensive game plans did not position Milroe for success. Additionally, wide receiver Germie Bernard defended Milroe against allegations of favoritism in targeting receivers, indicating internal support for the quarterback amidst external criticism.
As the Crimson Tide look ahead, DeBoer’s approach to the quarterback position will be pivotal. With Milroe’s future uncertain—he has yet to declare for the 2025 NFL Draft—DeBoer’s decisions in managing and potentially developing quarterback talent will be critical in determining whether Alabama can rebound from a disappointing season and reestablish its dominance in college football.