ESPN Analyst Paul Finebaum Doubts Indiana Football’s Playoff Hopes
ESPN analyst Paul Finebaum recently expressed skepticism about Indiana’s College Football Playoff (CFP) aspirations, dismissing the Hoosiers as a true contender. While Indiana has enjoyed a breakout season under head coach Tom Allen, Finebaum remains unconvinced that the program has the staying power to secure a playoff spot.
Finebaum pointed to Indiana’s historically inconsistent performance in the Big Ten, noting that the Hoosiers have long been overshadowed by powerhouse programs like Ohio State and Michigan. Despite their impressive wins this season, including a notable upset over Penn State, Finebaum argued that Indiana’s success is more of a product of other teams’ struggles rather than their own dominance.
One of Finebaum’s main concerns is Indiana’s lack of elite talent, particularly when compared to the traditional powers of college football. While the Hoosiers have a solid defense and a competent offense, Finebaum questioned whether they have the depth and skill to compete with teams like Ohio State, Alabama, or Georgia, should they face them in the playoff.
Additionally, Finebaum pointed to Indiana’s remaining schedule, suggesting that the Hoosiers may face difficulties maintaining their current level of play against top-tier opponents down the stretch. He also cited the likelihood that a one-loss Indiana team, particularly one that does not win the Big Ten Championship, would be hard-pressed to make the final four due to the committee’s historical preference for teams from power conferences with more established track records.
Ultimately, while Finebaum acknowledged Indiana’s progress, he argued that they are still a step behind the true playoff contenders and may find their Cinderella run cut short in the end.